In industrial networking, there has been a misconception for a decade: "If unmanaged switches can work, don’t choose light-managed switches . Many junior engineers have a simple logic: fewer functions mean lower problems. But is that really? This article will help you find how to choose the right industrial switch for different industrial scenarios.
1. Misconceptions about Unmanaged and Light-managed Industrial Switches
Almost all engineers who choose unmanaged industrial switches cite "stability" as the primary reason before. However, this viewpoint was only right before 2010.
2. The Biggest Differences Are "Fault Isolation Capability" and "Observability"
If we only talk about the differences in function, you could list a long table outlining that light-managed switches support VLANs, QoS, and ring networks, but unmanaged switches do not. However,the fundamental differences are fault isolation capability and observability. These are also the two core requirements of industrial networking environments.
If the production line used light-managed switch, this downtime would not have occurred, because light-managed switches support port isolation, support each device's broadcast domain to be separated. A failure in one device would not affect others; Light-managed switches also support broadcast storm suppression, automatically limiting the broadcast packet flow per port, even if one device malfunctions, it will not bring down the entire network; Additionally, light-managed switches automatically log fault information, notifying you: "Port 7 detected a broadcast storm at 15:22 and has automatically limited the flow." The onsite maintenance engineer could solve the problem within 10 minutes.
3. When to use unmanaged switches or light-managed switches?
Based on the above, we have summarized a simple selection framework for practical industrial scenarios.
· Isolated devices: a single CNC machine, barcode scanners, individual temperature and humidity sensors ;
· Temporary short-term projects: temporary site monitoring, exhibition networking, short-term testing platforms;
· Any scenarios requiring ring network: Ring network is the most basic redundancy solution for industrial networks, but unmanaged switches do not support.and one single point of failure can bring down the whole network;
· Scenarios with more than 8 devices: When there are more than 8 devices, the probability of broadcast storms will increases exponentially, and unmanaged switches cannot cope with that;
· Scenarios involving industrial cameras or visual inspection: Industrial cameras are very sensitive to bandwidth and latency. Unmanaged switches lack QoS, resulting in frame loss and packet delay;
· Critical devices on the production line: PLCs, robots, motion controllers, any network interruption will cause the production line shutdown;
· For long term projects: the operation and maintenance costs will be much higher than equipment purchase costs.
Today's industrial light-managed switches have almost become the standard configuration for industrial scenarios. They could perfectly balance cost, function and stability. Firstly, the price is only 1/3 to 1/2 of fully managed switches; Secondly, function can cover 95% of the needs of industrial scenarios; Thirdly, stability is comparable to unmanaged switches, and may even be better; Fourthly, operational costs are much lower than unmanaged switches. Especially for current storage chip prices rising, light- managed switches have become the good optional solution.
If you have any questions about selecting industrial switches or need to consult technical parameters of industrial switches, please visit the Rayin Technology official website (www.szrayin.com) for consultation.
Managed vs Unmanaged Network Switches: What Actually Sets Them Apart?
Industrial Networking Myth: Is Unmanaged Always More Stable Than Smart Managed?
Managed Industrial Switches: What Are the Differences Between L2, L2+ and L3 Models?
About the author: Sara is a Customer Manager at Rayin with over 10 years of experience in the communications field. In her free time, she enjoys badminton and swimming.