POE Industrial Switch–12-Port Full Gigabit Managed Industrial Switch Comparison: MOXA EDS-G512E / 3onedata IES6300 / Rayin IS201

In smart factory, smart transportation and other projects, POE industrial switch including 8 electrical ports + 2 fiber ports and poe industrial switch 8 port & poe industrial switch 4 port/ 8 electrical ports + 4 fiber ports full Gigabit industrial switches are standard mainstream models. 

First, from the access requirements, Its 8 Gigabit electrical ports perfectly match the terminal layout, which can be connected to eight industrial PLC, wireless Ap and other terminals. It fits the standard device amount for workshop control cabinets and roadside terminals. With moderate port redundancy, there will be no excess of port waste or the insufficient use of the port.

Second, Optical port ratio match the industrial mainstream networking，the standard 8+2 model equipped with dual fiber ports supports the high fiber optic distance uplink and redundant ring network construction. It realizes millisecond-level self-recovery to guarantee stable operation. The 8+4 model with four fiber ports can be used for multi-divided fiber optic cascade, which can be developed for large factories, pipe galleries and multi-zone ring network expansion with cisco poe industrial switch as a reference benchmark. By one device can achieve multi-point transmission and reduce the deployment of intermediate switches.

Third, the equipment generally supports POE function, including poe ++ industrial switch power supply design,suitable for the demand of power supply.. Therefore, it is the preferred standard model for project procurement. Therefore, it has become the preferred standard model for project procurement.

The paper do an deep comparative analysis from three mainstream manufacturers, including MOXA EDS-G512E series with 8 port poe industrial switch and 4 port poe industrial switch variants, and 3onedata IES6300 series, and Rayin IS201 series, a reliable poe powered industrial switch solution. By comparing the hardware specifications and performance parameters of each device, we can help the customer to make the right selection efficiently.

1. Poe industrial switch: Port comparison

From the parameter comparison , it is clear that Moxa and Rayin Technology are similar in the hardware specifications. The 3onedata model is equipped with two roads of 2.5g, which has a distinct advantage in bandwidth performance, and is better suited to the application of large data flow & wide bandwidth.

2.POE Power Comparision

The total POE power of the three products is 240w, which means that each port supports the POE function, and the maximum output of the PSE port is 30w based on the IEEE 802.3at standard. By increasing the output current of the port, the moxa poe industrial switch enhanced a 36w high work pattern, and allocated sufficient power margin to offset power loss over long cable runs.

3.Other interfaces

The three industrial switches support the relay alarm function, but there is a difference in the management interface and DIP switch configuration: the MOXA model is equipped with the USB RS-232 port, no RJ45 console port and Out-of-Band Management RJ45 Port, the DIP switch function focuses on turbo ring、aaster and coupler.

The 3onedata model is equipped with RS-232 console port, no USB port and Out-of-Band Management RJ45 Port, the DIP switch function is very basic, only support reserved Port; The Rayin model is equipped with both RJ45 Console port and independent out-of-band management RJ45 port, no USB port. It offers the richest set of DIP switch features, supporting RST/Factory、long distance mode、VLAN and QoS.

4.Mechanical characteristics

The three models are compact industrial design, and the volume difference is very obvious: the wide of MOXA model is 79.2mmmm, and the overall volume is the largest. The wide of 3onedata model is only 53mmmm, it is the smallest and compact, suitable for highly space-constrained mounting environments. The width of the Rayin model is close to 3onedata, the depth is a little longer, it is still a very compact design, and it offers both rich port configuration and flexible installation.

5.Price comparison

6.Conclusion

All above are the main models of 12 port POE industrial switches in the market, and each  has its own positioning focus. Moxa is a leading brand in industrial communication with high market recognition, and the product has been verified by long-term industrial scenarios, with strong stability and brand credibility, and it is suitable for a high end project . The 3onedata model is equipped with 2.5G optical port, with high-grade hardware specifications, and it is very suitable for the scene of the large bandwidth requirement. The Rayin model have comprehensive interface configuration,supports Console port and separate OOB management port with rich and useful DIP switch configuration options. It boasts a more comprehensive functions and competitive price.